Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Star Wars Thread 1: The Phantom Post
Chorrol.com > Chorrol.com Forums > General Discussion
Pages: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20
TheCheshireKhajiit
QUOTE(SubRosa @ May 6 2017, 11:14 PM) *

QUOTE(TheCheshireKhajiit @ May 7 2017, 12:07 AM) *

QUOTE(SubRosa @ May 6 2017, 11:03 PM) *

QUOTE(Uleni Athram @ May 6 2017, 08:49 AM) *

A little Fridge Moment for the day; in Ahsoka,



I don't think this is really too spoilery. In The Clone Wars tv show Sidious was trying to get his hands on the list of force sensitive children in the galaxy, as well as kidnap some of them to experiment on. I forget if he actually got the list of not. If so, he had plenty of candidates to choose from. But he also may have been training his inquisitors before the Clone Wars even took place. Dooku might have been training them before the war as well as well.

I was also under the impression that the Grand Inquisitor and perhaps some of the others were Jedi or Padawans who had fallen to the Dark Side. Which makes for a quick way to stock the Inquisition.

Wasn't Ventress or someone trying to kidnap force sensitive children in The Clone Wars? Or was it Cad Bane?

It was Cad Bane. He stole the holocron with the list of children, and kidnapped some of them and took them to Mustafar.
Who was he working for in that mission? Sidious?
SubRosa
QUOTE(TheCheshireKhajiit @ May 7 2017, 12:40 AM) *

QUOTE(SubRosa @ May 6 2017, 11:14 PM) *

QUOTE(TheCheshireKhajiit @ May 7 2017, 12:07 AM) *

QUOTE(SubRosa @ May 6 2017, 11:03 PM) *

QUOTE(Uleni Athram @ May 6 2017, 08:49 AM) *

A little Fridge Moment for the day; in Ahsoka,



I don't think this is really too spoilery. In The Clone Wars tv show Sidious was trying to get his hands on the list of force sensitive children in the galaxy, as well as kidnap some of them to experiment on. I forget if he actually got the list of not. If so, he had plenty of candidates to choose from. But he also may have been training his inquisitors before the Clone Wars even took place. Dooku might have been training them before the war as well as well.

I was also under the impression that the Grand Inquisitor and perhaps some of the others were Jedi or Padawans who had fallen to the Dark Side. Which makes for a quick way to stock the Inquisition.

Wasn't Ventress or someone trying to kidnap force sensitive children in The Clone Wars? Or was it Cad Bane?

It was Cad Bane. He stole the holocron with the list of children, and kidnapped some of them and took them to Mustafar.
Who was he working for in that mission? Sidious?

Yes, Sidious hired him to do both.
TheCheshireKhajiit
QUOTE(SubRosa @ May 6 2017, 11:42 PM) *

Yes, Sidious hired him to do both.

Well given that it's not a huge leap to suppose Sidious actually found some Force Sensitives on his own and trained them to be the Inquisitorious.
Callidus Thorn
QUOTE(TheCheshireKhajiit @ May 7 2017, 04:58 AM) *

QUOTE(SubRosa @ May 6 2017, 10:48 PM) *
*snip*

Khajiit would pee his pantaloons if they would do a show set in the Mandalorian Wars era Old Republic. This one is thinking an animated series might be the best medium for that. Ooh! Maybe it could initially follow a young Mission Vao as she follows Grif around before he finally ditches her on Taris. Then she meets up with the survivors of the Endar Spire. This way we could see the main story of KotOR without having the amnesiac Revan as the main character! Khajiit thinks it could work!


If they were going to do something with that era, I'd like to see two series: the first following Malak through the Mandalorian Wars, the second centering on Bastila for the Jedi Civil War. Malak would give us a good view of the Mandalorian Wars without having to step into Revan's shoes, and Bastila's story from KotOR is more coherent than Revan's, since she doesn't have amnesia to deal with and was involved from the start.

And, of course, we'd have to see something from Trask Ulgo! laugh.gif
TheCheshireKhajiit
QUOTE(Callidus Thorn @ May 7 2017, 05:06 AM) *

And, of course, we'd have to see something from Trask Ulgo! laugh.gif

Heh, right up until the point he's killed by the most unimpressive Dark Jedi ever! tongue.gif

Yes, that's right. Khajiit is revoking his Darth status on the grounds that he was never worthy of the title!
Callidus Thorn
QUOTE(TheCheshireKhajiit @ May 7 2017, 11:10 AM) *

QUOTE(Callidus Thorn @ May 7 2017, 05:06 AM) *

And, of course, we'd have to see something from Trask Ulgo! laugh.gif

Heh, right up until the point he's killed by the most unimpressive Dark Jedi ever! tongue.gif

Yes, that's right. Khajiit is revoking his Darth status on the grounds that he was never worthy of the title!


I'm sorry, but I'm going to have to disagree with your claim that Bandon was the most unimpressive dark jedi ever. Khan's Brotherhood of Darkness(from Path of Destruction) was full of far less impressive wielders of the dark side, who didn't even try to claim the title of Darth.
TheCheshireKhajiit
QUOTE(Callidus Thorn @ May 7 2017, 09:05 AM) *

QUOTE(TheCheshireKhajiit @ May 7 2017, 11:10 AM) *

QUOTE(Callidus Thorn @ May 7 2017, 05:06 AM) *

And, of course, we'd have to see something from Trask Ulgo! laugh.gif

Heh, right up until the point he's killed by the most unimpressive Dark Jedi ever! tongue.gif

Yes, that's right. Khajiit is revoking his Darth status on the grounds that he was never worthy of the title!


I'm sorry, but I'm going to have to disagree with your claim that Bandon was the most unimpressive dark jedi ever. Khan's Brotherhood of Darkness(from Path of Destruction) was full of far less impressive wielders of the dark side, who didn't even try to claim the title of Darth.

Hmm, Khajiit never read that. They were so incompetent it basically proved to Bane that the Sith were better off with the Rule of Two, right?
Callidus Thorn
QUOTE(TheCheshireKhajiit @ May 7 2017, 03:15 PM) *

QUOTE(Callidus Thorn @ May 7 2017, 09:05 AM) *

QUOTE(TheCheshireKhajiit @ May 7 2017, 11:10 AM) *

QUOTE(Callidus Thorn @ May 7 2017, 05:06 AM) *

And, of course, we'd have to see something from Trask Ulgo! laugh.gif

Heh, right up until the point he's killed by the most unimpressive Dark Jedi ever! tongue.gif

Yes, that's right. Khajiit is revoking his Darth status on the grounds that he was never worthy of the title!


I'm sorry, but I'm going to have to disagree with your claim that Bandon was the most unimpressive dark jedi ever. Khan's Brotherhood of Darkness(from Path of Destruction) was full of far less impressive wielders of the dark side, who didn't even try to claim the title of Darth.

Hmm, Khajiit never read that. They were so incompetent it basically proved to Bane that the Sith were better off with the Rule of Two, right?


Their leader was influencing all their minds, turning the Sith into a cult of personality where everyone was supposed to be equal(hence the rejection of the "Darth" title), though some were more equal than others, and they all followed his lead. The Rule of Two came partly from his training with the Brotherhood on Korriban, partly from the study of the archives there, and partly from his time studying Darth Revan's holocron.

I'd recommend the first book of the Darth Bane trilogy, Path of Destruction, but I'm not so much of a fan of the latter two.
TheCheshireKhajiit
Khajiit has a question about The Clone Wars.
SubRosa
The Palpster was at the trial. But I don't think he ever saw Ahsoka as a tool he could use. I think he was focused solely upon Anakin. Her leaving the Jedi Order (and thusly leaving Anakin), was a big triumph for him. It removed one of Anakin's greatest sources of emotional and moral support, and made him much more vulnerable to falling to the Dark Side. So I think if Palpatine had a choice, he would want Ahsoka as far away from Anakin as possible.

And honestly, I just don't ever see Ahsoka falling, under any circumstances. Like Obi-Wan, she was just made of sterner stuff. Palpatine never appears to have considered trying to turn Obi either.
TheCheshireKhajiit
QUOTE(SubRosa @ May 7 2017, 10:47 AM) *

And honestly, I just don't ever see Ahsoka falling, under any circumstances. Like Obi-Wan, she was just made of sterner stuff. Palpatine never appears to have considered trying to turn Obi either.

That could be true about Ashoka never turning, on the other hand, she had her own brushes with the Darkside. Ashoka feeling like the Jedi betrayed her could've been cultivated into anger and hate, with the right influence, which Palpatine was all about influence. Also, Khajiit doesn't think Obi would have been a very good target for recruitment by Palpatine because he hadn't had a falling out with the Jedi Order.
hazmick
QUOTE(TheCheshireKhajiit @ May 7 2017, 05:07 PM) *

That could be true about Ashoka never turning, on the other hand, she had her own brushes with the Darkside. Ashoka feeling like the Jedi betrayed her could've been cultivated into anger and hate, with the right influence, which Palpatine was all about influence. Also, Khajiit doesn't think Obi would have been a very good target for recruitment by Palpatine because he hadn't had a falling out with the Jedi Order.


Palpatine would never recruit Ahsoka anyway since he had Anakin. Rule of Two, and all that.
TheCheshireKhajiit
QUOTE(hazmick @ May 7 2017, 11:24 AM) *

QUOTE(TheCheshireKhajiit @ May 7 2017, 05:07 PM) *

That could be true about Ashoka never turning, on the other hand, she had her own brushes with the Darkside. Ashoka feeling like the Jedi betrayed her could've been cultivated into anger and hate, with the right influence, which Palpatine was all about influence. Also, Khajiit doesn't think Obi would have been a very good target for recruitment by Palpatine because he hadn't had a falling out with the Jedi Order.


Palpatine would never recruit Ahsoka anyway since he had Anakin. Rule of Two, and all that.

Oh Khajiit wasn't saying he would recruit her to make her a Darth.
SubRosa
QUOTE(TheCheshireKhajiit @ May 7 2017, 12:07 PM) *

QUOTE(SubRosa @ May 7 2017, 10:47 AM) *

And honestly, I just don't ever see Ahsoka falling, under any circumstances. Like Obi-Wan, she was just made of sterner stuff. Palpatine never appears to have considered trying to turn Obi either.

That could be true about Ashoka never turning, on the other hand, she had her own brushes with the Darkside. Ashoka feeling like the Jedi betrayed her could've been cultivated into anger and hate, with the right influence, which Palpatine was all about influence. Also, Khajiit doesn't think Obi would have been a very good target for recruitment by Palpatine because he hadn't had a falling out with the Jedi Order.

Every force user has their brushes with the dark side. It is part of using the Force, and growing in power. Everyone feels hate, anger, and fear at some point or another. But not everyone allows them to rule their lives. Obi-Wan watched Maul murder the woman he loved. But he still didn't fall. I just think that Ahsoka is made of the same stuff as Obi-Wan, not Anakin.
TheCheshireKhajiit
QUOTE(SubRosa @ May 7 2017, 11:54 AM) *

QUOTE(TheCheshireKhajiit @ May 7 2017, 12:07 PM) *

QUOTE(SubRosa @ May 7 2017, 10:47 AM) *

And honestly, I just don't ever see Ahsoka falling, under any circumstances. Like Obi-Wan, she was just made of sterner stuff. Palpatine never appears to have considered trying to turn Obi either.

That could be true about Ashoka never turning, on the other hand, she had her own brushes with the Darkside. Ashoka feeling like the Jedi betrayed her could've been cultivated into anger and hate, with the right influence, which Palpatine was all about influence. Also, Khajiit doesn't think Obi would have been a very good target for recruitment by Palpatine because he hadn't had a falling out with the Jedi Order.

Every force user has their brushes with the dark side. It is part of using the Force, and growing in power. Everyone feels hate, anger, and fear at some point or another. But not everyone allows them to rule their lives. Obi-Wan watched Maul murder the woman he loved. But he still didn't fall. I just think that Ahsoka is made of the same stuff as Obi-Wan, not Anakin.

Oh ok, Khajiit see's your point.
TheCheshireKhajiit
Oh look. ModDB has Jedi Academy mods.
SubRosa
Twi'lek's FTW! Is that outfit one of the vanilla ones? Or a mod?

I thought the stormtroopers doing what they do best would be shooting and missing! laugh.gif

What a piece of junk! laugh.gif
TheCheshireKhajiit
QUOTE(SubRosa @ May 8 2017, 03:32 PM) *

Twi'lek's FTW! Is that outfit one of the vanilla ones? Or a mod?

I thought the stormtroopers doing what they do best would be shooting and missing! laugh.gif

What a piece of junk! laugh.gif

Yes, her outfit is the first vanilla torso, and either the second or third vanilla legs. The only thing modded (on her character model that is), is her skin color and her saber blade color. Khajiit downloaded two mods, one was a general texture overhaul and the other was Jedi Academy Enhanced which added things like RGB saber blade sliders, player tint (which on most characters is clothing color, but skin color on Twi'lek), a couple of new force powers (one for each alignment), and some other tweaks.

Regarding the Stormies, that's exactly what Khajiit was getting at! Jaden is at point blank range and they still didn't hit her! This usually leads to the thing they do second best, which is what the Stormie on the right is doing!
SubRosa
I have read the first few issues of the Poe Dameron comic, and learned a few things. Firstly some timeline things.

4 ABY - Battle of Endor
5 ABY - Battle of Jakku (with it the end of the Empire, and the seed of the First Order traveling to Wild Space).
28 ABY - The novel Bloodline (and the first glimpse of the First Order being somewhere out there)
34 ABY - The Poe Dameron comic and following it The Force Awakens movie.

In Poe #1 we find that there is some sort of peace between The First Order and the New Republic. The Resistance fighters are under strict orders not to fire upon the First Order unless they are fired upon first. The reverse seems to be in effect as well.

That seems interesting, as I would have expected the First Order to burst upon the scene by immediate attacks upon the Republic. But instead in the 6 years between Bloodline and The Force Awakens they seem to have slowly emerged, but not gone to open war. I now suspect that they were biding their time until Starkiller base was operational. In Bloodline Leia knows very little about the First Order, not even their name. Just that there is some nameless threat growing beyond the edge of known space that most of the Republic is ignoring (but some are secretly financing).

By Poe #1, Leia and the Resistance clearly know what they are up against. In fact Poe has been intercepting intelligence reports from First Order spies.

In Bloodline Ben is still at Jedi school with Luke. So his betrayal and murder of the other Jedi took place somewhere between 28 ABY and 34 ABY. I just realized that one of the first things Anakin did when he fell was kill the Jedi younglings in the Temple on Coruscant. It looks like the first thing Ben/Kylo did was kill all of Luke's other students (though my guess is they were not children). So following in grandpa's footsteps.

This also implies that Rey was marooned on Jakku sometime before Luke's school fell. In her flashbacks she was a young child when she was left on Jakku. My guess is around 8 years old. That would put it at around 24 ABY. Four years before Bloodline. But why would Luke send her to Jakku more than four years before Ben/Kylo fell and killed everyone. Assuming that is why she ended up on Jakku? Maybe one has nothing do with the other (but I doubt it, considering Rey's vision seems to have put here there). Or maybe Lucasfilm mucked up the timeline already...
TheCheshireKhajiit
QUOTE(SubRosa @ May 8 2017, 08:56 PM) *

I have read the first few issues of the Poe Dameron comic, and learned a few things. Firstly some timeline things.

4 ABY - Battle of Endor
5 ABY - Battle of Jakku (with it the end of the Empire, and the seed of the First Order traveling to Wild Space).
28 ABY - The novel Bloodline (and the first glimpse of the First Order being somewhere out there)
34 ABY - The Poe Dameron comic and following it The Force Awakens movie.

In Poe #1 we find that there is some sort of peace between The First Order and the New Republic. The Resistance fighters are under strict orders not to fire upon the First Order unless they are fired upon first. The reverse seems to be in effect as well.

That seems interesting, as I would have expected the First Order to burst upon the scene by immediate attacks upon the Republic. But instead in the 6 years between Bloodline and The Force Awakens they seem to have slowly emerged, but not gone to open war. I now suspect that they were biding their time until Starkiller base was operational. In Bloodline Leia knows very little about the First Order, not even their name. Just that there is some nameless threat growing beyond the edge of known space that most of the Republic is ignoring (but some are secretly financing).

By Poe #1, Leia and the Resistance clearly know what they are up against. In fact Poe has been intercepting intelligence reports from First Order spies.

In Bloodline Ben is still at Jedi school with Luke. So his betrayal and murder of the other Jedi took place somewhere between 28 ABY and 34 ABY. I just realized that one of the first things Anakin did when he fell was kill the Jedi younglings in the Temple on Coruscant. It looks like the first thing Ben/Kylo did was kill all of Luke's other students (though my guess is they were not children). So following in grandpa's footsteps.

This also implies that Rey was marooned on Jakku sometime before Luke's school fell. In her flashbacks she was a young child when she was left on Jakku. My guess is around 8 years old. That would put it at around 24 ABY. Four years before Bloodline. But why would Luke send her to Jakku more than four years before Ben/Kylo fell and killed everyone. Assuming that is why she ended up on Jakku? Maybe one has nothing do with the other (but I doubt it, considering Rey's vision seems to have put here there). Or maybe Lucasfilm mucked up the timeline already...

Khajiit is very interested in Rey's lineage and circumstances. This one thinks it's obvious she will be a descendant of Anakin, but which sibling, Luke or Leía? Could Rey be a Solo and Ben not even know? If she is Luke's daughter, who was her mother and why did he leave his own child an orphan on Jakku? So many fun questions!
hazmick
QUOTE(SubRosa @ May 9 2017, 02:56 AM) *
Or maybe Lucasfilm mucked up the timeline already...

I wouldn't be surprised.

Maybe Luke knew what was going to happen with his school, but either couldn't or wouldn't stop it and sent Rey away as a contingency plan. The Force works in mysterious ways.
TheCheshireKhajiit
QUOTE(hazmick @ May 8 2017, 09:48 PM) *

QUOTE(SubRosa @ May 9 2017, 02:56 AM) *
Or maybe Lucasfilm mucked up the timeline already...

I wouldn't be surprised.

Maybe Luke knew what was going to happen with his school, but either couldn't or wouldn't stop it and sent Rey away as a contingency plan. The Force works in mysterious ways.

Khajiit has no doubt that Luke thought it would be best for Rey to be on Jakku. What could've transpired to bring him to that awful decision? That leaving a young girl alone on a strange planet is better than what might happen if she stayed with him? It may be like you said, Ben/Kylo destroying his academy, but Khajiit *suspects* it may be something deeper than that. Maybe something with Snoke?
SubRosa
I read up to the most recent Poe Dameron comic today. I also finished Before The Awakening. It is basically three short stories, one each for Finn, Rey, and Poe. They tell their stories before The Force Awakens.

Finn's was perhaps the most illuminating. He was one of the best stormtroopers in his training unit. But he had one terrible flaw. He felt compassion. First he tried to help one of his squadmates who was failing. Then later they were brought in to supposedly restore order at a mining outpost that supposedly was being manipulated to rise up because of Republic agents. It turns out the miners were slaves trapped on the asteroid the mine was in, slowly being starved to death and suffering injury after injury from the unsafe working conditions. They staged a strike. Captain Phasma met with their leaders to negotiate. Which is to say, she ordered Finn and his squad to kill them all. Finn didn't do it, but the others did of course. In the end Finn is being sent out on the mission to Jakku, feeling that there is something wrong with him, because he does not belong.

Rey's story does not really impart much new. Just mostly about how life sucks on Jakku. The biggest revelation might be that in her At-At home she has a Y-Wing monitor screen and some flight simulator software (the realistic kind, for training pilots), which she uses all the time for both entertainment and to learn to fly. That is why she is such a good pilot. It also shows where she learned so much about starship mechanics. She has spent her entire life not only stripping wrecks, but at one point she even took a crashed freighter and got it working again using parts cannibalized from other ships.

Poe's story starts with him flying for the Republic, and shows how he joined the Resistance. It ends just as he is given the assignment of finding Max Von Sydow (and right where the Poe Dameron comic begins. His story shows us a lot more of the Shadow War going on between the First Order and the Resistance. Both sides are technically adhering to the Galactic Concordance that officially ended the rebellion, and while each is under orders not to fire on the other, that rule gets broken a lot. It just happens when it's out of sight and unproveable. The First Order seems to be buying time for Starkiller Base to be finished. The Resistance is buying time to build up strength for the inevitable war.

All in all the book gives a lot more background to the new Force Awakens era, and really helps set up the movie and its characters.
hazmick
QUOTE(SubRosa @ May 10 2017, 09:27 PM) *

His story shows us a lot more of the Shadow War going on between the First Order and the Resistance. Both sides are technically adhering to the Galactic Concordance that officially ended the rebellion, and while each is under orders not to fire on the other, that rule gets broken a lot. It just happens when it's out of sight and unproveable.


That's very reminiscent of the background in SWtOR - the Sith Empire and Republic technically have a peace treaty, but by either working through intermediaries, having people pretend they're working alone, or doing stuff in very remote locations, they manage to have a pretty big conflict going on in secret.

Seems some things never change.

SubRosa
QUOTE(hazmick @ May 10 2017, 04:36 PM) *

QUOTE(SubRosa @ May 10 2017, 09:27 PM) *

His story shows us a lot more of the Shadow War going on between the First Order and the Resistance. Both sides are technically adhering to the Galactic Concordance that officially ended the rebellion, and while each is under orders not to fire on the other, that rule gets broken a lot. It just happens when it's out of sight and unproveable.


That's very reminiscent of the background in SWtOR - the Sith Empire and Republic technically have a peace treaty, but by either working through intermediaries, having people pretend they're working alone, or doing stuff in very remote locations, they manage to have a pretty big conflict going on in secret.

Seems some things never change.

That might be where they got the idea from!

I don't really mind it, because they have shown that both sides have a reason to continue the farce of peace. It is obvious that it will not last.

Speaking of working through intermediaries, that was in Poe's story. He and two other pilots had a mission to get the evidence that a Republic Senator was working with the First Order. The senator was taking numerous trips to the borderlands between Republic and First Order space. Leia wanted to get the navigational data from his ship's computer to prove he was actually traveling to FO space. But the senator wiped the data every time he landed. So Poe had to intercept his ship in space, board it, and get the info. They did so by using some old Z-95 Headhunters and impersonating pirates. The First Order showed up to 'rescue' the senator, and Poe and company had to fight their way out.

I also did not have time to mention that the Poe Dameron comic shows us how Black Squadron was formed, and puts names and a little backstory to a few of the faces in those X-Wings in the movie. Sadly it is only a few, as one character dies before the film, another deserts/goes on the run after rescuing his wife from slavery, and a third actually gets a promotion to leading a different squadron.

Another interesting thing I am seeing is that it is not an accident there are so many young faces in the First Order in the movie. From what we saw of the First Order's creation at the end of the Empire's End trilogy, and now in the new books, the FO is not simply a continuation of the Empire. It is new, built around those feral children that Admiral Sloane took with her to Wildspace after Jakku. That explains why Hux is a general and yet still in his twenties. All of the First Order people were taken as children and molded into what they are. Like Finn. It makes them very loyal, since they have never known anything but the propaganda the FO wants them to know. But it also makes them inexperienced. They spend a lot of time training. But there is training, and then there is real action. They have not seen action.

The Poe Dameron comic introduces a First Order spy named Terex, who is actually a former Imperial Stormtrooper who fought on Jakku. After the war he became a pirate, and much later joined the First Order when it returned to the known galaxy. Captain Phasma does not like him much though, she is pretty contemptuous of him in fact. Because he was part of the old Empire. The First Order consider themselves superior to that, untainted. So while the First Order is essentially the successor to the Empire, they consider themselves above it.

In contrast many of the Resistance fighters and leaders are veterans of the Rebellion. From Leia and Ackbar on down to fighter pilots like Lu'lo (we see him both the Shattered Empire comic and Poe Dameron comic) and Snap Wesley (he was a mid-teen during the Rebellion, but he flew an X-Wing at Jakku). The First Order might have numbers, but the Resistance has the experience. The difference really shows in their dogfights.
Crimson Paladin
QUOTE(SubRosa @ May 10 2017, 02:27 PM) *

Finn's was perhaps the most illuminating. He was one of the best stormtroopers in his training unit. But he had one terrible flaw. He felt compassion. First he tried to help one of his squadmates who was failing. Then later they were brought in to supposedly restore order at a mining outpost that supposedly was being manipulated to rise up because of Republic agents. It turns out the miners were slaves trapped on the asteroid the mine was in, slowly being starved to death and suffering injury after injury from the unsafe working conditions. They staged a strike. Captain Phasma met with their leaders to negotiate. Which is to say, she ordered Finn and his squad to kill them all. Finn didn't do it, but the others did of course. In the end Finn is being sent out on the mission to Jakku, feeling that there is something wrong with him, because he does not belong.

You wouldn't know that the film though, where Finn seems to spend most of his time trying desperately to not die while people are constantly swinging things at him.

I hope the next film actually lets us see the "elite soldier" side of him, because it's something I've felt the films have always been missing. It's always criminals, Jedi, pilots, or politicians that save the day, but never simple soldiers.
Dark Reaper
QUOTE(TheCheshireKhajiit @ May 8 2017, 01:25 PM) *


Pilot: Thank you it belong to my brother whose now deceased .
SubRosa
I just caught something while watching TFA. When Rey is giving the list of former owners of the Falcon, one of the gangs she mentions is the Irving Boys. When Poe pretends to be a pirate in Before The Awakening, he told the crew of the ship he was hijacking that he was one of the Irving Boys! biggrin.gif So that is a nice little tie-in.

I also noticed that in Maz Kanata's cantina, when Maz tells Finn that he can trade work for passage on a ship, it is the Crimsion Corsair that she is pointing to, from The Crimson Corsair and the Lost Treasure of Count Dooku.

QUOTE(Crimson Paladin @ May 10 2017, 05:32 PM) *

QUOTE(SubRosa @ May 10 2017, 02:27 PM) *

Finn's was perhaps the most illuminating. He was one of the best stormtroopers in his training unit. But he had one terrible flaw. He felt compassion. First he tried to help one of his squadmates who was failing. Then later they were brought in to supposedly restore order at a mining outpost that supposedly was being manipulated to rise up because of Republic agents. It turns out the miners were slaves trapped on the asteroid the mine was in, slowly being starved to death and suffering injury after injury from the unsafe working conditions. They staged a strike. Captain Phasma met with their leaders to negotiate. Which is to say, she ordered Finn and his squad to kill them all. Finn didn't do it, but the others did of course. In the end Finn is being sent out on the mission to Jakku, feeling that there is something wrong with him, because he does not belong.

You wouldn't know that the film though, where Finn seems to spend most of his time trying desperately to not die while people are constantly swinging things at him.

I agree. Finn seems to be basically an everyman character, who is very easy to relate to, feel sympathy for, and laugh with. But I suppose the thing to keep in mind is that the top 1% of the stormtrooper class is not quite the same as the top 1% of the jedi, senator, or smuggler class... wink.gif
Darkness Eternal
Okay . . . question for you guys. Anyone else get irritated when good stuff is deleted from the script and replaced with, well, not so stellar material? George Lucas had plenty of opportunities to make a GREAT story in Revenge of the Sith but he left some major stuff out. Substance.

In the original script for Episode III, Padme was a major character in planting the seeds and contributing the creation of the Rebel Alliance. The novel and deleted scenes explains some of it when Padme and major characters like Bail and Mon Mothma speak about Chancellor Palpatine and his position in the senate.

Apparently, Padme was going to kill Darth Vader . . . with a knife . . . on Mustafar . . . Wow. blink.gif

Obi-Wan shows up. Vader freaks out . . . and fighting begins. blink.gif

Here's the video. It starts at 28 minutes in.

George. What the hell George . . . .What. The. Hell.
Dark Reaper
QUOTE(Darkness Eternal @ May 10 2017, 07:26 PM) *

George. What the hell George . . . .What. The. Hell.


I----I think I'm going to cry verysad.gif . I always said the prequels could have been good but George had to much control over the films.
Crimson Paladin
Hey Werewolf&Vampire. Good to see you again.

QUOTE(Darkness Eternal @ May 10 2017, 06:26 PM) *

Okay . . . question for you guys. Anyone else get irritated when good stuff is deleted from the script and replaced with, well, not so stellar material? George Lucas had plenty of opportunities to make a GREAT story in Revenge of the Sith but he left some major stuff out. Substance.

In the original script for Episode III, Padme was a major character in planting the seeds and contributing the creation of the Rebel Alliance. The novel and deleted scenes explains some of it when Padme and major characters like Bail and Mon Mothma speak about Chancellor Palpatine and his position in the senate.

Apparently, Padme was going to kill Darth Vader . . . with a knife . . . on Mustafar . . . Wow. blink.gif

Obi-Wan shows up. Vader freaks out . . . and fighting begins. blink.gif

Here's the video. It starts at 28 minutes in.

George. What the hell George . . . .What. The. Hell.

I'm still miffed at her dying because she "lost the will to live".
Darkness Eternal
QUOTE(Crimson Paladin @ May 11 2017, 07:32 PM) *

Hey Werewolf&Vampire. Good to see you again.

QUOTE(Darkness Eternal @ May 10 2017, 06:26 PM) *

Okay . . . question for you guys. Anyone else get irritated when good stuff is deleted from the script and replaced with, well, not so stellar material? George Lucas had plenty of opportunities to make a GREAT story in Revenge of the Sith but he left some major stuff out. Substance.

In the original script for Episode III, Padme was a major character in planting the seeds and contributing the creation of the Rebel Alliance. The novel and deleted scenes explains some of it when Padme and major characters like Bail and Mon Mothma speak about Chancellor Palpatine and his position in the senate.

Apparently, Padme was going to kill Darth Vader . . . with a knife . . . on Mustafar . . . Wow. blink.gif

Obi-Wan shows up. Vader freaks out . . . and fighting begins. blink.gif

Here's the video. It starts at 28 minutes in.

George. What the hell George . . . .What. The. Hell.

I'm still miffed at her dying because she "lost the will to live".

I'd make far more sense if Sidious was draining her life force to sustain Vader. That's a popular theory anyway, or
Somehow Vader did unknowingly. But the whole "lost the will to live" in my opinion could have been left out.
Dark Reaper
QUOTE(Crimson Paladin @ May 11 2017, 01:32 PM) *

I'm still miffed at her dying because she "lost the will to live".


I like to think she died due to the injuries from getting forced choked. That's one thing I liked about KOTOR is that it explains what force choke does.
SubRosa
I think the problem was George Lucas. Amidala/Padme has to die, because we know that Luke and Leia were raised by adoptive parents, with no knowledge of their biological mother. Plus she is the last link between Anakin and the light side. I really cannot see him becoming Vader while she is still alive. She would always be a beacon of hope to pull him back.

But George Lucas has never known what to do with female characters on even his best days, and the prequel films were definitely not his best days. He had to get rid of Padme, but didn't know how. The obvious answer is that Anakin straight out kills her, but in such a way that Luke and Leia can still be born and survive. But I don't think George was willing go so far as to show Anakin actually murdering the mother of his children (and then Obi-Wan doing an emergency c-section with a lighstaber to save the kids). Let's face it, that is really vile and despicable. Way beyond force choking Admiral Ozzel. We know Vader is a bad guy, but I really don't think George Lucas wanted to show him doing anything that personal and horrific on film.

So in the end Lucas literally did nothing, and Padme dies.... just because. Meh.
TheCheshireKhajiit
QUOTE(SubRosa @ May 17 2017, 05:44 PM) *

I think the problem was George Lucas. Amidala/Padme has to die, because we know that Luke and Leia were raised by adoptive parents, with no knowledge of their biological mother. Plus she is the last link between Anakin and the light side. I really cannot see him becoming Vader while she is still alive. She would always be a beacon of hope to pull him back.

But George Lucas has never known what to do with female characters on even his best days, and the prequel films were definitely not his best days. He had to get rid of Padme, but didn't know how. The obvious answer is that Anakin straight out kills her, but in such a way that Luke and Leia can still be born and survive. But I don't think George was willing go so far as to show Anakin actually murdering the mother of this children (and then Obi-Wan doing an emergency c-section with a lighstaber to save the kids). Let's face it, that is really vile and despicable. Way beyond force choking Admiral Ozzel. We know Vader is a bad guy, but I really don't think George Lucas wanted to show him doing anything that personal and horrific on film.

So in the end Lucas literally did nothing, and Padme dies.... just because. Meh.

Not sure what the deal was with that. Georgie boy makes it clear that Anakin murdered a bunch of children at the Jedi Temple but draws the line at outright murdering a pregnant Padme? Very odd.
SubRosa
QUOTE(TheCheshireKhajiit @ May 17 2017, 08:28 PM) *

QUOTE(SubRosa @ May 17 2017, 05:44 PM) *

I think the problem was George Lucas. Amidala/Padme has to die, because we know that Luke and Leia were raised by adoptive parents, with no knowledge of their biological mother. Plus she is the last link between Anakin and the light side. I really cannot see him becoming Vader while she is still alive. She would always be a beacon of hope to pull him back.

But George Lucas has never known what to do with female characters on even his best days, and the prequel films were definitely not his best days. He had to get rid of Padme, but didn't know how. The obvious answer is that Anakin straight out kills her, but in such a way that Luke and Leia can still be born and survive. But I don't think George was willing go so far as to show Anakin actually murdering the mother of this children (and then Obi-Wan doing an emergency c-section with a lighstaber to save the kids). Let's face it, that is really vile and despicable. Way beyond force choking Admiral Ozzel. We know Vader is a bad guy, but I really don't think George Lucas wanted to show him doing anything that personal and horrific on film.

So in the end Lucas literally did nothing, and Padme dies.... just because. Meh.

Not sure what the deal was with that. Georgie boy makes it clear that Anakin murdered a bunch of children at the Jedi Temple but draws the line at outright murdering a pregnant Padme? Very odd.

Yes, but I do not believe he ever really showed Anakin actually killing the younglings. If I recall it was just a holo that cuts out after a Anakin takes a swing. It is a lot more visceral when you see the real thing right in your face.

It is similar to Alderaan being blown up. We see the planet being destroyed. But we never actually see a single person dying. The actual human toll is left purely to our imagination.
Dark Reaper
Well just a few more months till Episode 8: The Last Jedi comes out which I'm looking forward to, at least I don't have to collect any new E8 figures biggrin.gif .
Dark Reaper
Luke's Last Stand.
SubRosa
QUOTE(Dark Reaper @ Aug 5 2017, 08:40 PM) *

Don't worry Luke, Sabine to the rescue!
TheCheshireKhajiit
QUOTE(SubRosa @ Aug 5 2017, 08:14 PM) *

QUOTE(Dark Reaper @ Aug 5 2017, 08:40 PM) *

Don't worry Luke, Sabine to the rescue!

Mandalorians ftw!
Dark Reaper
QUOTE(SubRosa @ Aug 5 2017, 08:14 PM) *

Don't worry Luke, Sabine to the rescue!


Ghost Squad to the rescue #DakLives .

IPB Image
TheCheshireKhajiit
QUOTE(Dark Reaper @ Aug 5 2017, 08:45 PM) *

QUOTE(SubRosa @ Aug 5 2017, 08:14 PM) *

Don't worry Luke, Sabine to the rescue!


Ghost Squad to the rescue #DakLives .

IPB Image

Where's Hera?
Dark Reaper
QUOTE(TheCheshireKhajiit @ Aug 5 2017, 10:14 PM) *

Where's Hera?


In the cockpit, gotta keep the ship running for emergency take off.
happy.gif
TheCheshireKhajiit
QUOTE(Dark Reaper @ Aug 5 2017, 11:37 PM) *

QUOTE(TheCheshireKhajiit @ Aug 5 2017, 10:14 PM) *

Where's Hera?


In the cockpit, gotta keep the ship running for emergency take off.
happy.gif

Gotcha! That's what Khajiit figured.
Callidus Thorn
QUOTE(Dark Reaper @ Aug 6 2017, 01:40 AM) *


Okay, TIE Bomber on the left, Y-wing on the right, but what's that TIE next to it?

And is anyone else thinking that the Ghost Squad pic looks like there's a little "recreation" going on front and centre during that rescue? rollinglaugh.gif
Dark Reaper
QUOTE(Callidus Thorn @ Aug 6 2017, 04:10 PM) *

Okay, TIE Bomber on the left, Y-wing on the right, but what's that TIE next to it?

And is anyone else thinking that the Ghost Squad pic looks like there's a little "recreation" going on front and centre during that rescue? rollinglaugh.gif


The Tie next to the Y-Wing is the Tie Striker from Rogue One.


"There's a little "recreation" going on front and center"...

Not sure what it is, probably over my head tongue.gif.
Callidus Thorn
QUOTE(Dark Reaper @ Aug 6 2017, 11:13 PM) *

The Tie next to the Y-Wing is the Tie Striker from Rogue One.


That explains why I don't recognise it. I'll have to go poking through Wookiepedia to find it then.

QUOTE(Dark Reaper @ Aug 6 2017, 11:13 PM) *

"There's a little "recreation" going on front and center"...

Not sure what it is, probably over my head tongue.gif.


And here I thought I was aiming for the gutter

IPB Image
Dark Reaper
Gotta love these old Micro Machines playsets.

IPB Image
Callidus Thorn
Is it bad that I chuckled at seeing an A-Wing that's the same size as the Millenium Falcon? rollinglaugh.gif

Must be the one that took out the Executor bigsmile.gif
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2025 Invision Power Services, Inc.