QUOTE(SubRosa @ Apr 16 2017, 05:15 PM)

TBH, I am not glad to see losing the clear white hat / black hat morality. I like the Empire being the White Male Supremacists who are enslaving the entire galaxy and laying waste to entire worlds as they rape them of their natural resources. While the Rebel Alliance are the clear cut good guys out to stop them and return freedom and justice. Give me the Illinois Nazis In Space vs. the Blues Brothers any day.
That is what made Star Wars what it is today. If you look back and watch the original movies, there was nothing really special about them. The acting was not extraordinary. The stories are very simple (and often have some big plot holes). Even the whole genre of science fiction was nothing new or groundbreaking. The only thing truly remarkable about them was the special effects, where were beyond cutting edge at the time. ILM literally invented sfx all over again with those movies. But special effects do not make a movie good.
But they came at a time Post Vietnam, Post Civil Rights Movement, after America endured so much civil and moral upheaval, that no one wanted movies of complex morality or shades of gray. That is why the big movies in the early 70s were disaster flicks. Earthquake, Towering Inferno, the Airport movies, Jaws, etc... They were always Man vs Nature, where there was not question of good or evil. Just people trying to survive against all odds.
Then Star Wars burst on the scene with a very simple good vs. evil story. It was exactly what the country needed to escape the failed wars and race riots and assassinations and crooked politicians and social upheaval of the recent past. It let us forget the ugly issues of reality, and slip back into the joy of a world where right and wrong were simple choices. Even now, 40 years later, the real world is not a simple place. Star Wars provides a nice safe haven for a few hours to escape the ugly reality of terrorism and genocide and travel to a world where the good guys actually can win.
I am afraid that if Star Wars loses that foundation, that what makes the whole franchise special will erode as well. Then it will be just one of many sci fi franchises.
Gotcha! See, the thing is Star Wars appeals to a wide range of people, young and old. I totally see where you are coming from and I know many people agree. Star Wars, at its core, is also about the hero's journey.
All of the movies, all eight of them, from episode 1-8, and the spin-off and the series named Rebels, are about the Republic, the Jedi, the Rebellion/Resistance as the protagonists. And that's great, for those who enjoy it which I know is a wide range of people. And you mention the being the Empire being
"White Male Supremacists who are enslaving the entire galaxy and laying waste to entire worlds as they rape them of their natural resources." That's what the frame and narrative the movies have set them out to be, and its largely based on the point of view of the people who are fighting against them.
The main story of
Rebels itself is a group of heroes joining together as a crew to fight against the tyrannical and evil Empire to help save the galaxy. The original trilogy is just the same with heroes like Luke, Leia, Han and company. One thing comes to mind though, and that's Obi-Wan's quotes:
"The truths we cling to depend greatly on our point of view."The opening crawl from Revenge of the Sith states:
"There are heroes on both sides."The fresh narrative for
Battlefront II and
Inferno Squad does honor the Star Wars legacy of a hero's journey, but the frame is set through the lens of an Imperial soldier. And that appeals to many people. Because at the end of the day one man's hero is another man's villain. I'm certain many of the japenese citizens felt the United States were the villains when they launched a nuclear bomb on Hiroshima and Nagasaki, claiming countless lives. And I'll stop right there as to not get into a political discussion, but again the Empire has its heroes, the Sith has its heroes. A hero can be defined by a person who, well, does heroic things.
The developers of the game basically set us in a path of a young woman born and raised in an Imperial world, schooled in knowledge of an Imperial utopia: order, security, peace. These ideals, deeply rooted into someone, is very difficult to destroy. So you have the perspective of those soldiers who whole-heartedly believe that the galaxy was saved by an Emperor, and a gang of evil fanatics/mages known as the Jedi where destroyed and the Clone Wars came to an end along with the seperatists. Then we have a group of people suddenly rise up to threaten what they perceive is good and just, and plan to throw a galaxy back into chaos and to restore a failed government that was ripe with corruption. The stormtroopers, in their eyes, believe the Rebels are terrorists and extremists, and they themselves to be the heroes to uphold law and order and are the hopes of a safer, more secure galaxy.
It is, in a way, "good vs evil", only because we are playing as
one side. The Rebellion has heroes like Hera, Ezra, Sabine, Kanan Jarrus, Zeb, Jyn Erso, Luke and Leia Skywalker, etc and those are awesome stories to follow because they appeal to those who follow.
But the Empire has
their heroes have different shifts in perspectives when we step into the shoes of those villains(from the hero's point of view). I probably sound like a broken record, but one of the makers of the game said:
QUOTE
“If you are growing up in the Empire, Iden is exactly [a role model]. She is exactly that type of hero that you would look up to and that you would aspire to be, right? Because if you are a member of an Imperial academy, and you were trained into that and that’s what you believe in, that’s what you’ve been raised to sort of to become, she epitomises that. “She is still heroic on that level, just from a total different perspective. In a new point of view that we haven’t gone quite so deep in in Star Wars before.
tldr; Star Wars remains a great battle between good versus evil, and yet one man's evil is another man's good. I dare not quote Darth Vader about his point of view of the Jedi at the climax of Revenge of the Sith. The majority of fans sees the Empire as evil. Plenty of folks out there would be inclined to think otherwise, and that the rebellion are anarchists bent on upsetting the established order. The heroes are who we make them out to be.