QUOTE(mirocu @ Apr 23 2014, 12:27 PM)

And here I was, happy about Niamh´s successor..
Oh, well. Can´t fight the creator!

Sorry Mirocu.
Sometimes stories just don't work out the way we think. Eilidh C doesn't "soar" or live enough, her tale doesn't move me. Eilidh S, ah well now, there's a woman with a story to tell and the words to tell it flow onto the page; and so we spend our time with her.
To paraphrase Panic at The Disco: I write sins not comedies.
In short Eilidh C's story is too light and there's no sense of that slow curve that may lead to redemption or to an ascension of some sort. Eilidh S has that and more.